During the 2008 presidential campaign, then candidate Obama challenged Hillary Clinton’s assertion that some things must be kept secret in order to be an effective leader. He argued that in a democracy, the voting public must be informed. We all know that now President Obama sits on secrets that neither he nor career policy makers would like to divulge; because, in the end, information is power. The White House and the State Department both emerged to denounce the Wikileaks’ release of US embassies cables. Secretary of State Hillary Clinton was the first to condemn it, while Obama used his aides and the White House communication staff to condemn the act as “reckless and dangerous action.” Many analysts, observers, and foreign leaders also showed their displeasure. A close examination of the facts, however, would suggest that there is no consensus over the wisdom and impact of the release of diplomatic correspondences. In fact, a case can be made that the availability of this information will help in the long run. First, while Secretary Clinton condemned the disclosure of the leaked documents, she claimed during the same event that these documents in fact help make the administration’s case against Iran. In other words, Secretary Clinton wants to have her cake and eat it, too. The same documents that she thinks the voters should not see also contain information that shows that Iran’s nuclear ambitions are “a concern shared by nations on every continent.” Moreover, although Wikileaks is the source of the leaked documents, it is the mainstream media that published them. The New York Times published a series of articles and achieved the documents on its main website. So did the Guardian and other major world media outlets. In other words, the mainstream media found that the correspondences are news worthy as well as substantively informative. It is safe to say that, had the government allowed “responsible” media access to these documents, the public would have been informed about these important issues without risk; and, surely, there would not have been a void to be filled by a website like Wikileaks in the first place. In a democracy, the voters decide on the people and the issues. Keeping important information secretive allows persons in power to cherry pick the information to suit their personal or partisan agendas. The cherry picking of intelligence information concerning Iraq’s (phantom) weapons of mass destruction program is still fresh in the mind of all and it will remain so especially in the minds of the families of the victims at home and abroad. The “irresponsible” dumping of 250,000 documents did not cause the death of innocent people as some predicted more than it embarrassed many Arab and foreign leaders who mastered doubletalk. If the Arabs (or other nations) are threatened by their neighbor Iran, they should and they must say so in public. They must be willing to risk it all, not goad and egg on the US to fight their battles. For this reason alone, the US government must provide more information to its citizens. The mainstream media left a void that was filled by Wikileaks and other blogs. The government ought to work with the media to make critical information available responsibly and timely; that will be the sure way of marginalizing irresponsible outlets.
December 3, 2010
Wikileaks Documents: split mind politics and democracy
Friday, December 03, 2010
No comments
About Assistants
Islamic Societies Review Editors
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Most read this week...
-
The Iran Deal: Iran P5+1 nuclear deal, Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action -- (full text)
-
by Foti Benlisoy and Annalena Di Giovanni Turkey A few months ago, in January 2013, an accident in a steel factory of Gaziantep, a...
-
On : Remembering Why Americans Loathe Dick Cheney By Conor Friedersdorf As the former vice president releases his memoir, it's useful...
-
by Ahmed E. Souaiaia* To preserve their rule, Arab leaders have relied on two arguments: they are needed to keep Islamism under cont...
-
In another sign of nervousness resulting from the mounting pressure put by the Arab revolts on authoritarian rulers, members of the GCC (...
-
( Arabic Text ) Part 1: The state Article 1 The Arab Republic of Egypt is a sovereign state, united, indivisible and inalienable. It...
-
... I. Iran and E3/EU+3 will take the following voluntary measures within the timeframe as detailed in this JCPOA and its ...
-
Economists specializing in the study of Islamic finance and economics have reduced Islamic laws governing financial and economic t...
-
by Ahmed E. Souaiaia * Abstract: Social labels and categories are exercise in control. They describe opponents, create boundaries,...
-
Interview in English translation: Interview in Arabic: Watch video The full text of the interview:
Our articles are filed under these labels:
2011 War
Afghanistan
Africa
Algeria
All
Arab Spring
Brazil
BRICS
China
Civil Society
Conflict
Democracy
Dignity
Dissent
Economics and Finance
Education and Communication
Egypt
Europe
Events
GCC
Global South
Human Rights
Ideas
India
International Affairs
International Law
Iran
Iraq
Islamic art
Islamic Societies
Islamic World
Journalism
Kurdistan
Law and Society
Lebanon
media
Middle East
Military
Music
Muslim Americans
Muslim Ban
North Africa
Palestine
Politics and Government
Poverty
Qatar
Racism
Religion and Culture
Religion and Politics
Russia
Saudi Arabia
Science and Technology
Souaiaia
South Africa
Syria
Terrorism
The Arab Spring in a Global Context
Tunisia
Turkey
Ukraine
United Nations
USA
Wahhabism
War and Peace
War Crimes
World and Communities
Yemen
مصادرة الإسلام
Find related articles...
Read it in your language
Subscribe
Trending
-
The Iran Deal: Iran P5+1 nuclear deal, Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action -- (full text)
-
by Foti Benlisoy and Annalena Di Giovanni Turkey A few months ago, in January 2013, an accident in a steel factory of Gaziantep, a...
-
On : Remembering Why Americans Loathe Dick Cheney By Conor Friedersdorf As the former vice president releases his memoir, it's useful...
-
by Ahmed E. Souaiaia* To preserve their rule, Arab leaders have relied on two arguments: they are needed to keep Islamism under cont...
-
In another sign of nervousness resulting from the mounting pressure put by the Arab revolts on authoritarian rulers, members of the GCC (...
-
( Arabic Text ) Part 1: The state Article 1 The Arab Republic of Egypt is a sovereign state, united, indivisible and inalienable. It...
-
... I. Iran and E3/EU+3 will take the following voluntary measures within the timeframe as detailed in this JCPOA and its ...
-
Economists specializing in the study of Islamic finance and economics have reduced Islamic laws governing financial and economic t...
-
by Ahmed E. Souaiaia * Abstract: Social labels and categories are exercise in control. They describe opponents, create boundaries,...
-
Interview in English translation: Interview in Arabic: Watch video The full text of the interview:
Reasoned Comments Archive
Most read this month...
-
The Iran Deal: Iran P5+1 nuclear deal, Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action -- (full text)
-
by Ahmed E. Souaiaia* To preserve their rule, Arab leaders have relied on two arguments: they are needed to keep Islamism under cont...
-
... I. Iran and E3/EU+3 will take the following voluntary measures within the timeframe as detailed in this JCPOA and its ...
-
( Arabic Text ) Part 1: The state Article 1 The Arab Republic of Egypt is a sovereign state, united, indivisible and inalienable. It...
-
by Ahmed E. Souaiaia * Abstract: Social labels and categories are exercise in control. They describe opponents, create boundaries,...
-
by Foti Benlisoy and Annalena Di Giovanni Turkey A few months ago, in January 2013, an accident in a steel factory of Gaziantep, a...
-
On : Remembering Why Americans Loathe Dick Cheney By Conor Friedersdorf As the former vice president releases his memoir, it's useful...
-
by Ahmed E. Souaiaia * Trump said many things that offended many people. Muslim Americans were among those offended by his ...
-
Economists specializing in the study of Islamic finance and economics have reduced Islamic laws governing financial and economic t...
-
Interview in English translation: Interview in Arabic: Watch video The full text of the interview:
Most read last 12 months
-
by Ahmed E. Souaiaia * Abstract: Social labels and categories are exercise in control. They describe opponents, create boundaries,...
-
Economists specializing in the study of Islamic finance and economics have reduced Islamic laws governing financial and economic t...
-
On this platform, the 2011 war in Syria was characterized as a proxy war before it became obvious that it was so. Here, too, the war in Ukra...
-
On July 25, the president of Tunisia, Kais Saied, cited article 80 of the ratified 2014 constitution to declare a national emergency. The ...
-
by Ahmed E. Souaiaia * Trump said many things that offended many people. Muslim Americans were among those offended by his ...
-
With every military operation in areas held by the so-called moderate opposition fighters, Western governments accuse the Syrian governmen...
-
On August 25-17, more than 200 Sunni Muslim scholars from around the world convened in Grozny, Chechnya, to answer the question:...
-
With a Russian-U.S. agreement intended to isolate them from the so-called moderate opposition groups, Salafist fighters could end up join...
-
Leaders of counties that are said to be the top 20 economies in the world met this weekend in China. We would like to summarize what happen...
-
Leaders of Russia and Turkey have agreed to create a demilitarized Idlib buffer zone in Syria’s northwestern province to separate govern...
Most read all time...
-
by Ahmed E. Souaiaia * Abstract: Social labels and categories are exercise in control. They describe opponents, create boundaries,...
-
Leaders of Russia and Turkey have agreed to create a demilitarized Idlib buffer zone in Syria’s northwestern province to separate govern...
-
by Ahmed E. Souaiaia * Less than a year after the start of the crisis in Syria, I warned that militarizing the Syrian uprisi...
-
by Ahmed E. Souaiaia* The leader of al-Nahda movement, Rachid Ghannouchi, made his first visit to a foreign country after the first po...
-
Economists specializing in the study of Islamic finance and economics have reduced Islamic laws governing financial and economic t...
-
by Ahmed E. Souaiaia * Trump said many things that offended many people. Muslim Americans were among those offended by his ...
-
On August 25-17, more than 200 Sunni Muslim scholars from around the world convened in Grozny, Chechnya, to answer the question:...
-
by Henelito A. Sevilla, Jr. * Recent gas attack to a civilian population in the suburbs of Syria that led to the death of hundre...
-
by Ahmed E. Souaiaia* Armed opposition groups operating inside Syria may have violated international humanitarian law by committing...
No comments:
Write commentsShare your thoughts...